I bet Batman never had a degenerative knee condition.
Degenerative: Adj. (of a disease or condition) getting steadily worse.
I know, I know, me of all people talking like this so close to Opening Day.
While I do not think Chase’s career is over, I can't stop thinking about the bigger picture, and how it could have been different.
When Chase first came up, every Phillies fan saw the whole beautiful picture playing out in their head. A long, happy marriage between a team, a city, and it's phenomenally good looking second baseman. A gritty, hard-working player whose unparalleled baseball mind could make anyone's heart melt (or maybe that's just me). No, his range at second wasn’t great, but we knew that because of his work ethic, it would come.
Yes, the first couple years were blissful. We could see MVP awards, Cooperstown and eventually, some cushy job as the team’s alumni ambassador, or something.
Then, that stupid pitch from John Lanaan in 2007 broke his hand.
That's where things got shaky for our hero. A cranky hip throughout 2008 required surgery after the celebrations ended. A sprained thumb in 2010, and then the knee problems started. All in all, he's missed 106 games in the last two years.
The numbers certainly aren't what we expected. Most players would be thrilled to have a career .290 batting average with an .882 OPS and 1,198 hits. But, we’re talking about the difference between a solid Major Leaguer and the legend we thought Chase might become. If he had stayed healthy, and kept on pace with his 2006 season (160 games, .309 BA with 32 HRs, 102 RBI and 40 doubles), it's easy to imagine what his career numbers could have looked like. He has fallen out of the top five in most Fantasy Baseball rankings for second basemen and after five straight years on the list, he hasn’t cracked the top 10 in WAR since 2009.
It's hard not to think about the what-ifs. What if Chase hadn't gone to college and started in the system earlier? (Actually that one's easy, he would have been playing for the Dodgers.) But what if Chase didn't have to wait for the Phillies to clear space for him? What if he hadn't played in so many games early on? The speculations are endless, but it doesn't seem to matter much now. Now is a 33-year-old second baseman with a degenerative knee condition shrouded in mystery and secrecy by a general manager whose remarks on the subject usually involve “different stretches and exercises.”
I am in no way shape or form acting like Chase is dead or that the Phils never have a chance to win again – because they do. If anything, I'm already nostalgic about this core group of guys, the ones who brought us a parade and so many good memories. It’s hard to imagine the Phillies without Chase, Ryan and Jimmy, but it seems the end of this love affair is closer than we thought. After almost 10 years, it’s hard to say how many more summers we have left with this group of players together.
The 2012 Phillies are still incredibly talented, experienced and, oh yeah, there are still those three guys in the rotation. This team will not fade from contention, but they need to pull together, regardless of who takes the right side of the infield. Like an aging pitcher with less velocity, it’s time to reassess the arsenal, and find a way to win, even if it means adopting a different strategy. For the fans, it’s time to start letting go of the “what-ifs” and focusing on what’s on the field – what I believe is still one of the best teams in baseball.
Even if Chase can never get back to 100%, we should count ourselves lucky for getting the chance to watch him play when he was healthy (and that the team around his has gotten so much better). He brought a lot of passion back into Philadelphia baseball and the organization owes him a lot for getting them to where they are.
But, maybe our hero will surprise us all yet. Because, after all, “Chase Utley, you are the man.”